Yet what Thomas Paine said of monarchy in 1776 is equally true of bureaucracy today: âA long habit of not thinking a thing wrong gives it a superficial appearance of being right.
Related Quotes
This shift from autocracy to democracy didnât occur spontaneously, nor was it led from the top. Instead, it was the work of a sprawling confederation of philosophers, protesters, and patriots who were inspired by the promise of self-government.
Our organizations are less than fully human because they were designed to be so. Writing in the early twentieth century, Max Weber, the pioneering German sociologist wrote: â[B]ureaucracy develops more perfectly the more it is âdehumanized,â the more it succeeds in eliminating all purely personal, irrational and emotional elements which escape calculation.â Then as now, the goal of bureaucracy was to turn human beings into semi-programmable robots.
Aristotle argued that an individual cannot achieve happiness without self-direction. If we believe that a just society is one in which people have the opportunity and freedom to become their best selves, then we shouldnât tolerate the soft tyranny that millions of employees face each day at workâwhat oral historian Studs Terkel called âa Monday through Friday kind of dying.
If your worldview places a premium on human freedom and growth, youâll regard the inhumanity of bureaucracy as intolerable and feel compelled to act. If, on the other hand, you regard human beings as factors of production, youâll make excuses for bureaucracy and be content with minor reforms.
Before moving on, letâs recap:
- Bureaucracies are replication machines. Theyâre designed for exploit, not explore.
- Bureaucracies tend to be monocultures. Theyâre run by individuals temperamentally inclined to favor the status quo.
- Bureaucratic information systems fail to capture the hidden costs of one-sided trade-offs. As a result, many decisions are underinformed and, therefore, suboptimal.
- Bureaucracies tend to enforce uniform trade-offs across the entire organization. Though unsophisticated, this preserves the centerâs power and sense of order.
- The bureaucratic aversion to ambiguity leads to either/or thinking. Rather than maintaining a creative tension, organizations tend to whipsaw between counterposed priorities.