Research shows that the most accurate criticism would come from a leaderās direct reports, because they have the closest knowledge of the leaderās performance.
Related Quotes
...you have probably experienced a particular form of bad management displayed by bosses who seem unaware of their limitations and are clearly and unjustifiably pleased with themselves. They are overconfident, abrasive, and very much in awe of themselves, particularly in light of their actual talents.
Womenās self-reports of confidence had no correlation with how others saw their confidence.
Summing up, if someone has the right intellectual capital, social capital, and psychological capital, they will have more potential to be a good leader. But itās not guaranteed.
As a consequence, organizations often assume that a leaderās career success reflects his or her performanceāthe more senior a leader, the more talented the person must be.
But even more critically, we must put in place much bigger obstacles for the disproportionate glut of incompetent men who are so adept at becoming leaders, to everyoneās peril.